In his essay “The Moral Philosopher and the Moral Life,” William James describes a thought experiment in which an idyllic society's existence depends on the abject suffering of a single individual. Ursula K. Le Guin’s short story, The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas: Variations on a Theme by William James, makes this experiment more pointed and poignant by describing this beautiful society, its city, and its citizens in lyrical detail: a glorious place, filled with blissful, fully actualized people.
It is a perfect utopia.
It is too good to believe. “Do you believe?” the unidentified narrator asks. “No? Then let me describe one more thing.”
In a basement of one of the beautiful buildings of this city, there is a child. It may be a boy or a girl, we are told. Because we don’t know which, the child’s pronoun is “it.” “It” is a pronoun reserved for objects. It is objectified, made less than human. Its suffering, both physical and psychological, is described in detail. So malnourished, it has stopped growing. It is kept locked in a cramped, cold, dirty, dim room. No one may even show it kindness. Terrified and alone, no one comes to visit it.
Except– sometimes people come to see it. It is no secret. Every single person in Omelas knows about this child. At a certain age, the other children of the city are told about it. Other than brief viewings, the child remains out of sight.
The child and its suffering are accepted as completely normal. We aren’t told the origins of this practice, so it seems like it has just always been. Because of this the practice goes unquestioned. We don’t question what is considered normal.
When people do reflect on the possibility of releasing the child, they reason that it wouldn’t know how to exist outside its cage. That’s where it belongs. Le Guin writes, “It has been afraid too long ever to be free of fear. Its habits are too uncouth for it to respond to humane treatment.” It is considered natural, not a construct born out of belief.
It is not explained why or how this is so, but we are told that the good fortune of the city depends entirely upon the existence of this child and its suffering. Le Guin lays out the terms: “They all know that it has to be there. Some of them understand why, and some do not, but they all understand that their happiness, the beauty of their city, the tenderness of their friendships, the health of their children, the wisdom of their scholars, the skill of their makers, even the abundance of their harvest and the kindly weathers of their skies, depend wholly on this child's abominable misery.” It must suffer for the good of everyone else in Omelas, including all the other children, who are beloved and cherished by the entire community. It is necessary.
Normal, natural, and necessary. These are what psychologist Dr. Melanie Joy calls the three N’s of justification, which violent dominant ideologies employ to vindicate and sanction the harm that they do. As Dr. Joy explains, these are myths that become embedded in violent dominant ideologies so deeply that they are treated as facts and are not challenged. The mythical quality of the practice of the child in the basement comes through Le Guin’s narrative in the lack of explanation for how and why it must be so. We know only what we are told, and we are told: “the terms are strict and absolute.” There is no room for questioning. But standing outside the society as visitors or onlookers, the absence of explanation and the absurdity of the claims are obvious to us. In fact, the bizarre rationalization the people make for not freeing the child go so far as to imagine: “Indeed, after so long it would probably be wretched without walls about it to protect it, and darkness for its eyes, and its own excrement to sit in.”
The Ones Who Walk Away From Omelas is commonly read as a parable of violent ideologies that maintain their power over a society while justifying the profound harm they do to marginalized groups. Male dominance, slavery, and heterosexual supremacy, Dr. Joy says, have all used these myths of “normal, natural, and necessary” to justify their injustice and cruelty and to maintain their power structures. These ideologies are not only violent; they are also invisible to those in the midst of them, like the fair and good people of Omelas, who cannot see the absurdity of their beliefs.
Animals in Omelas
Carnism, illuminated and named by Dr. Melanie Joy, the ideology that allows us to justify eating some animals while loving others, and speciesism, the belief in human supremacy over all other animals that allows us to use animals however we see fit, are dominant ideologies that operate under these same myths of justification. We live in a culture where we are taught, and we believe, that animals are here for our use, pleasure, and whims. We believe it is normal, natural, and necessary to eat and use animals and animal products.
Furthermore, like the child in the basement with no identity of its own, animals are thought of as objects. We distance ourselves from animals used for food by obscuring them psychologically through language and cognitive dissonance. Other than our own companion animals, we are likely to call an animal “it” rather than “he” or “she.” We refer to the parts of the animals we eat: wings, legs, breasts, loins. Or we rename the body parts we eat entirely: bacon, venison, pork, beef.
Just as everyone knows about the child in the basement, we know-on-some-level about the lives and deaths of farmed animals. But, like the child, they are kept out of sight, locked in factory farms. When we do think of them, we rely on the myths of the three N’s of justification to soothe our conscience.
This allows us to live in the Omelas of Carnism, under the spell of this invisible violent ideology.
Le Guin calls her story The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas. Who are these ones who walk away and why do they matter? It happens that sometimes an adult or young person will go to see the child. They go to see the child, and then leave the city. We don’t know where they go, but we are left hoping it might be to a better place. The ones who walk away reject the unquestioned violence and injustice of Omelas. To Le Guin, they are pivotal. She didn’t call it Omelas or The People of Omelas or even The Child in the Basement, though sometimes readers refer to it that way. I think this is important, and it signifies a key point I’ll come back to at the end of this essay. But Le Guin called it The Ones Who Walk Away From Omelas. These unnamed characters are crucial to Le Guin’s narrative because they offer a counterpoint, suggesting that the system is indeed flawed - so flawed, so corrupt - that these individuals can no longer bear to live there, can no longer bear to be part of it. The ones who walk away pierce the veil of the myth of Omelas. And seeing clearly, they reject it.
Le Guin describes how this happens, “At times one of the adolescent girls or boys who go see the child does not go home to weep or rage, does not, in fact, go home at all. Sometimes also a man or a woman much older falls silent for a day or two, then leaves home. These people go out into the street, and walk down the street alone. They keep walking, and walk straight out of the city of Omelas, through the beautiful gates... They leave Omelas; they walk ahead into the darkness, and they do not come back.”
When I became an ethical vegan, I thought of myself as “one who walked away.” I’ve been living quietly in the new country of Veganism. It is better. And I can see clearly the myths of Carnism for what they are. But other people do not like the veil of myth being pierced; they resist knowing too much; as Maria Montessori said, “people shun horrors.” So, like the ones who quietly leave Omelas, I learned to be silent about it. Jokes about vegans being too outspoken. Not wanting to be “that vegan.” Retorts like “it’s a personal choice.” Studies about vegans being less likable than drug dealers. All these things kept me quiet, hoping others would follow my lead and “walk away” from Carnism.
But years passed, and something grew in my heart. It wasn’t enough to live quietly by example. It was perhaps that I heard a soft, pleading cry, a cry that grew louder and more persistent, a cry from beneath a building in the city I left behind.
The child was still in the basement. Is still there.
Animals are suffering. They are bred into it and die by it.
So, my book Intelligence of Love is my way of walking back, returning to Omelas. I want to help the bright, kind, loving people of Omelas see through their myths, and free the child from its obscurity, objectification, and suffering.
I wish Le Guin had written this part of the story. I don’t have a map; I don’t know how it will go. But I hope to bring the traditions of my new country with me, lead with compassion as I walk the streets of Omelas, stopping to ask people: “Have you thought of the child today?” Listen with patience as they repeat the words of the myths they have been told and believe to be true. Attempt, gently and thoughtfully, to get them to question their beliefs, to convince them that theirs is no utopia that depends upon the suffering of an innocent being. I don’t think it will be easy. It might be heartbreaking. But it might also be joyous and heartwarming. I hope they will listen. I hope I will find community with others who have returned to try to free the child.
Whatever happens, I can’t leave now; I can’t go back to being quiet. Not until the people of Omelas are free from the prison of their beliefs. Not until all the children of Omelas are free and beloved, happily forever after.
Postscript
One of the most trying myths of Omelas to dispel is the strange idea that the anger and sorrow some of the people feel about the child's suffering (without doing anything to help) elevates them in their own esteem. They care about the child, they feel for it, and their compassion and helplessness to do anything for the child is - they believe - their own prison. Their happiness comes at a cost that they are aware of, and so - again, they believe - it is a more profound, meaningful happiness that further proves their eminence and goodness.
As Le Guin writes, “Yet it is their tears and anger, the trying of their generosity and the acceptance of their helplessness, which are perhaps the true source of the splendor of their lives. Theirs is no vapid, irresponsible happiness. They know that they, like the child, are not free. They know compassion.” Remarkably, they manage to make the child’s extreme suffering about themselves.
This oddly framed attitude reminds me of the hobby or small-scale farming movement. These hobby farmers and their well-heeled customers make the animals’ suffering about themselves (they feel terrible about how animals in the food system are treated), and so their solution (providing a better life than a factory farm) is designed to make them feel better about themselves (while they still enjoy meat and animal products) but does nothing to save the animal, who is still slaughtered well before the end of his or her natural lifespan.
“They know compassion,” and that is a true sign of deep goodness of heart. But this is a slippery kind of compassion that can trick them away from truly good outcomes. It is a morally selective and self-exculpatory kind of compassion that is easy to mistake for real do-gooding. In his book, Against Empathy, Paul Bloom warns against an empathy that is merely sentimental because it spotlights only a select few, like the few animals on a hobby farm, who are treated with care (until they are slaughtered) and given some slight moral consideration, while it excludes and further obfuscates the billions of other animals languishing in factory farming. It becomes easier not to think of animals in factory farms when you see a few well-kept cows grazing in a bucolic setting, and never see the ones in factory farms. It advertises this myth of happy cows, pigs, and chickens, and in this way, works to support industrial animal agriculture, which depends on the perpetuation of these myths.
Bloom suggests a different kind of compassion, “rational compassion,” which is akin to intelligence of love. It is compassion based not merely on sentiment and self-exculpation, but on broader awareness, consideration of factual information, and deeper understanding. In the case of farmed animals, a rationally compassionate approach should heighten awareness and care for all farmed animals; it should advertise the cruelty and damage of factory farming to animals, humans, and the environment; and it should deepen understanding of animal sentience, the sentimental lie of “humane slaughter,” and the role of speciesism in setting up our myths of human supremacy. Ultimately, a rational compassion would put an end to using animals for farming and other human exploits, when it isn’t a matter of human survival.
My final point, returning to the title, is that Le Guin’s story is centrally about the child in the basement. It’s not about the people living happily in the glorious city, aware-and-unaware of their complicity. It’s not about the ones who walk away and reject the myths and the violent system the myths perpetuate. And it’s not about the ones who return to try and break the spell and free the child. It is about the child who suffers alone in the dark, whose freedom is the only thing that should matter.
Of course it involves all of us: the mythbound citizens, the conscientious objectors, the activists, and the victims. Our fortunes and futures are bound together, and a better world for all of us lies in following the intelligence of love.